Implementation of
Perioperative Cardiac Risk Reduction Therapy (PCRRT) Using Beta
Blockers and Clonidine (BBAC) - continued
Despite the proven effects of PCRRT for the reduction of
perioperative mortality, the low cost per life saved and the
adoption by the ACC and AHA in 1996 and the reissue in 20036,7
of perioperative perioperative cardiac risk reduction therapy
using beta blockers or clonidine (PCRRT), changing physician
practice is slow. In a recent survey 90% of anesthesiologists
had heard of perioperative beta blockade (PCRRT) and 40% were
using it.28-30
Unfortunately, PCRRT therapy has not been adopted universally
for a number of reasons including lack of education about
the therapy, lack of knowledge about contraindications to
beta-blockade, lack of understanding about how to implement
an effective PCRRT program29,30,
anesthesiologist hesitation about prescribing an oral medication31,
lack of feedback about the benefits of adopting PCRRT, and
lack of feedback of the risks of not adopting the PCRRT program.
Anesthesiologists started preoperative beta-blockers infrequently
even in patients without contraindications.31,32
Moreover, a significant fraction (30%) of high risk patients
with clear indications for perioperative beta blockade, who
are admitted on beta blockers, have them discontinued.32
These findings suggest that educating anesthesiologists about
the perioperative use of beta-blockade may increase the use
of this therapy proven to reduce perioperative mortality.29,31
In international studies, 90% of anesthesiologists were aware
of peri-operative beta-blockade, unfortunately specific protocols
were available in only 10% of institutions.28-30
To obtain a worldwide 90%
|
familiarity with and 40% using the therapy in less than a
decade is phenomenal success for a therapy without any corporate
support.29
This accomplishment has been through academic detailing, national
and international lectures, publications, adoption of therapy
as a standard of care by the ACC and AHA, and web based education
(www.betablockerprotocol.com). Despite this world wide recognition
of the therapy, it is not utilized in all patients at risk.
Epidemiologic analysis of one hospital's experience with perioperative
care demonstrated that ninety-seven percent (97%) of the patients
who developed postoperative MI could have been identified
as being at increased risk for cardiac complications, and
eighty-one percent (81%) appeared to be ideal perioperative
beta-blocker candidates.33
Treatment with a beta-blocker before infarction was associated
with an odds ratio of in-hospital mortality of 0.19 (95% confidence
interval, 0.04-0.87) (81% reduction in the risk of death).33,34
A large percentage of the postoperative MI's could be prevented
if a beta-blocker had been administered to all ideal candidates
around the time of surgery. Use of beta-blockers before infarction
reduces overall mortality, even among patients who go on to
develop this complication.33
Recently we demonstrated in a prospective randomized clinical
trial that PCRRT with clonidine, an alpha-2 agonist also reduces
30 day and two year mortality.24
This trial provides a second line agent for patients who have
a specific contraindication to beta blockers.
The reductions in mortality with PCRRT can be most dramatic
when there is a protocol in place to guide PCRRT.35
In 1998, at the VAMC San Francisco we instituted a Perioperative
Cardiac Risk Reduction Therapy (PCRRT) program in patients
undergoing non-cardiac surgery. In reviewing our NSQIP data
for the
|
years since instituting that policy, we have been a statistically
significantly low outlier for 30-day mortality for major non-cardiac
surgery for five or the last six years. Prior to the PCRRT
program our five year average O/E ratio was 1.0. It has been
clearly demonstrated in prospective randomized clinical trials
that PCRRT reduces operative 4,24
and long term mortality4,19,24.
Adoption of the clinical use of perioperative PCRRT with beta
blockers at the VAMC San Francisco has cut our observed to
expected operative mortality.36
The American College of Cardiology and the American Heart
Association have stated that perioperative beta blocker therapy
for patients with elevated risk is a level 1 indication. The
consensus of medical experts25-27
suggest that perioperative beta blockers reduce operative
mortality. The prospective, randomized, clinical trials and
the epidemiologic analysis support the use of perioperative
beta blockers. Use of perioperative beta blockade at the San
Francisco VA is associated with a reduction in surgical mortality.
It is time to implement a program at your hospital for perioperative
beta blockade protocols which combined with education, computerized
analysis of compliance rates, feedback of compliance rates
and associated mortality rates, and computerized reminders
in medical record systems can reduce surgical mortality and
reduce patient care costs.
If you have not registered, please
register now.
Otherwise, begin the lessons by clicking below.
|